TTW Nest · College, work, and adult lifeNovember 2026
Home / Research / Questions / Reading
Research and evidence

Who gets to decide what counts as a research problem?

An expert can miss a problem that students encounter every Tuesday.

Imagine a college surveys neurodivergent students about a mentoring program that administrators already bought. Students can rate the mentors and write a comment. Then someone declares the program “student-centered.”

They did ask students a question. But who decided that mentoring was the problem to solve?

A different starting point

Orlando Fals-Borda helped develop participatory action research, combining research with meaningful participation and action. The people living with a problem help define it, investigate it, and act on what they learn.

Vincent and collaborators demonstrate one way students can help produce accounts of university life rather than merely answer researchers' questions. Community writing, including Nick Walker's essays, can also challenge an academic field to notice assumptions that its usual methods overlook.

That does not mean every personal account is a population estimate or every participatory project produces an effective intervention. It means the question of who holds the authority belongs in the method, not just in the acknowledgments.

What the current evidence says

The 2026 review of 37 intervention studies found very little documented co-design with neurodivergent students. That's a design gap worth addressing. But it doesn't prove that simply using a co-design label will improve outcomes.

How to make participation real

Give students a say in which problem is studied. Pay them for substantial work. Make decisions accessible. Be explicit about who can overrule whom. Publish what changed and what didn't. Invite disagreement, including when students dislike an initiative that staff are proud of.

What would change our minds? Comparative evaluations of student-led and staff-designed interventions, with measures of student authority as well as eventual outcomes.