TTW Nest · College, work, and adult lifeNovember 2026
Home / Research / Questions / Reading
Research and evidence

What counts as success at a Community College?

Graduation matters. It also isn't everybody's reason for being there.

A college is supposed to improve student success. Fine. But which success?

For one student, it's a degree. For another, a transfer. For someone else, a certificate, the ability to travel to campus independently, or a first semester that makes a return to education feel possible.

What numbers can and cannot tell us

Bakker and colleagues tracked academic progression and completion over time. Longitudinal studies are valuable because a snapshot from one semester cannot tell the whole story. But a university dataset in the Netherlands does not become a universal Community College benchmark simply because it is a large dataset.

Karp and Bork show how institutional expectations can shape whether students can navigate college at all. That's a different piece of the puzzle: what do students need to understand and do, and which barriers did the college create?

The 2026 engagement review reminds us that studies measure engagement in different ways. Engagement, belonging, retention, progression, and graduation are connected ideas, not interchangeable statistics.

Neither extreme works

If we measure only degrees, we miss some real gains and may misunderstand students who came for another legitimate goal. If we measure only satisfaction, we can congratulate ourselves while students aren't progressing toward anything they chose.

A stronger evaluation includes the student's goals, the institution's outcomes, and measures of the process. Are students learning something useful? Are they making choices? Are doors opening? Are there unnecessary hurdles?

What I would track

Define cohorts carefully, include students who haven't registered with disability services where appropriate and ethical, and report which indicators you used. Disaggregate where privacy permits. Follow up. When someone leaves, find out whether they achieved a goal, faced a barrier, transferred, or simply decided to do something else.

What would change our minds? More longitudinal Community College work based on student-defined goals alongside traditional completion indicators. That would give us a fuller picture without excusing real gaps.