Is Universal Design just learning styles with better marketing?
No. But it is still possible to apply UDL badly.
People do learn differently, but that is not the same as saying everyone is a permanent “visual learner” or “auditory learner.” We can retire that particular sorting hat.
Two claims that sound similar but aren't
The learning-styles matching claim says that if we discover someone's style, teaching in the corresponding format improves learning. Pashler and colleagues reviewed the evidence and found no adequate support for making that general approach standard practice.
Universal Design for Learning asks a different question: How can a learning environment anticipate barriers and offer meaningful ways to engage with and demonstrate the intended knowledge or skill? Its framework includes multiple ways of representing information and expressing learning, but it is not a system for diagnosing everyone with a fixed learning identity.
Where it can go wrong
An instructor might produce seven versions of an assignment while failing to explain its actual goal. That's not inclusive design; that's a great deal of extra work around an unclear assignment.
In some courses the mode is essential. A student training to give an oral presentation needs to practice speaking, even if written communication is their strength. The sensible question is what support and preparation make that essential skill accessible, not whether to abolish the skill.
Vygotsky is useful here because support can be part of the learning process. It should be responsive to what the learner can do now and what they can do with help. But don't confuse that theory with proof that one specific worksheet or digital tool works.
Try this
Write the learning objective in plain language. Identify which requirements are essential, which are habits of the instructor, and which are accidental barriers. Offer options for the accidental barriers. Evaluate whether students can show the targeted competence.
What would change our minds? Strong, well-described comparisons of specific instructional changes, measured by the learning they are meant to improve, rather than checking whether someone said they “used UDL.”