TTW Nest · College, work, and adult lifeNovember 2026
Home / Research / Questions / Reading
Research and evidence

Why does college expect students to know rules nobody taught them?

The hidden curriculum is not a character test.

Every institution has unwritten rules. You are supposed to know when to email a professor, how to challenge a grade without sounding rude, what “participate actively” means, and whether a deadline has an unofficial grace period. Some students arrive knowing those rules. Others have to discover them by getting something wrong.

What the research says

Karp and Bork interviewed students and staff at three Community Colleges and described the student role as a collection of academic and nonacademic expectations. Their point was not that students are incapable. It was that expectations frequently go unexplained.

CAST's UDL guidance gives us a way of thinking about the problem: anticipate learner variation and make learning routes more accessible from the start. But remember the distinction. Karp and Bork studied college expectations. CAST supplies design guidance. Neither paper is a controlled trial proving that a particular email template raises completion rates.

Why this matters

If a student doesn't know what office hours are for, “go to office hours” is not a complete instruction. If a rubric says “professional communication” without describing what counts, students can be evaluated for failing a test nobody knew they were taking.

None of this requires lowering standards. Explain the standard. Provide examples of work that meets it. Then hold students responsible for the standard rather than for reading your mind.

What to do on Monday

Take one common request, such as “ask for help early.” Write the steps as someone new to college would see them. Who should they contact? What do they say? How soon is “early”? What if the person doesn't reply?

Test the instructions with students who haven't used that service. Watch where they hesitate. If everyone has the same question, that's information about the instructions.

What would change our minds? Intervention studies that compare clear procedural teaching to usual practice and measure whether students actually navigate campus more successfully, without increasing an exhausting amount of required training.