TTW Nest · College, work, and adult lifeNovember 2026
Home / Research / Questions / Reading
Research and evidence

Does mentoring actually work?

Promising results, small studies, and one very important question about who gets to mentor whom.

A lot of colleges offer mentoring to neurodivergent students. It sounds sensible. Someone who knows the place helps a newcomer decode the place. What's not to like?

Quite a lot, actually, if we skip the details. Mentoring can mean an autistic peer helping another autistic student find community, a non-autistic student reminding someone about deadlines, or a trained employee providing executive-function coaching. Those are three very different services hiding under one familiar word.

What the studies tell us

Duerksen and colleagues found nine different peer mentoring programs reported across eleven articles. The evaluations frequently described positive social, academic, or belonging-related outcomes. That is encouraging. But the studies tended to be small, often qualitative, and difficult to compare.

The 2026 review of 37 interventions and 59-article engagement review make much the same broader point: programs can be promising without giving us a reliable, portable effect size. “Students liked it” is a good thing to hear. It is not the same as “this improved degree completion.”

A particularly interesting detail comes from the MOSSAIC evaluation. Autistic mentees described real benefits, but some said they wanted autistic mentors. Having to teach your mentor the basics of being autistic isn't exactly the support you signed up for.

What we can reasonably infer

Structured mentoring deserves serious consideration. The research also suggests that relationship fit, training, boundaries, and student choice are not optional decorations. They shape what mentoring actually is.

What we cannot infer is that every campus should buy the same mentoring package or that a mentor will automatically improve graduation. The evidence does not support that leap.

A better way to test it

Before launching a mentoring program, ask students what they want a mentor to do. Help with finding classrooms? Decoding faculty emails? Meeting people? Practicing conflict repair? Those require different training and different measurements.

Give students choices about whom they work with, pay attention to privacy, and review whether the mentor is building agency or merely managing the student. Then measure outcomes appropriate to the goal. A mentoring program can be worthwhile without claiming it solved retention.

What would change our minds? Larger comparative studies with clear outcomes, sustained follow-up, neurodivergent co-design, and descriptions detailed enough for another college to reproduce the approach.