Should students have to disclose to get help?
The difference between formal accommodations, everyday access, and telling people more than they need to know.
A student can know exactly what help would make a course accessible and still decide not to tell an instructor about a diagnosis. That isn't automatically denial, immaturity, or lack of self-advocacy. It may be a reasonable decision.
Formal disability accommodations often involve a documented process. That process matters. So does the question of which changes could have been available to everyone in the first place.
The evidence
In Frost and colleagues' interviews, twenty autistic college students described complex relationships with identity and community. They often disclosed selectively, asking whether sharing information would help someone understand them or instead invite assumptions.
Grimes and colleagues studied students who had not disclosed disabilities to an Australian university. They found substantive reasons for remaining outside the formal support process, including difficulties with disclosure itself. It is a useful warning against interpreting low registration numbers as low need.
Roslin's legal analysis adds a different perspective: verification processes can create their own barriers. Legal rules must be assessed in context, but procedural burden is a real thing to examine.
What this does not mean
It does not mean institutions can ignore legal eligibility processes or grant every requested change regardless of the course's essential requirements. It also does not mean students are always safe or well served by staying silent. Some supports genuinely need coordination, and institutions have legal obligations that are not replaced by friendly intentions.
The point is to distinguish what the college must know from what a student should be free to keep private. Explaining an assignment more clearly should not require a medical record.
Try a two-route approach
First, build ordinary clarity into courses and services. Make directions accessible, let students ask questions in several formats, and explain how procedures work.
Second, maintain an understandable, confidential accommodations process for changes that require individualized assessment. Give students clear information about what documentation is needed, who receives it, and how decisions can be reviewed.
What would change our minds? Research comparing less burdensome access processes with traditional systems, tracking both equity and the actual quality of accommodations. Not just the number of forms completed.