TTW Nest · College, work, and adult lifeNovember 2026
Home / Research / Questions / Reading
Research and evidence

Can a college create belonging?

You can design conditions. You cannot hand someone a feeling.

Colleges like the word belonging. It fits nicely on a poster, which may explain some of its popularity. Unfortunately, a poster has never taught anyone how to register for a class, repaired a difficult conversation, or made a disability services process easier to use.

What the scholarship offers

Allen and colleagues revisit decades of belonging scholarship and the idea that acceptance and connection are important human motives. This is useful background. It is not a manual for producing belonging by next Tuesday.

The 2026 review shows that programs intended to help neurodivergent students can be studied, but their outcomes and designs vary widely. That makes a broad claim about “what builds belonging” difficult to defend.

Meanwhile, Frost and colleagues remind us that being seen as one's actual self matters. Some students want connections with other autistic people; others do not want to be sorted into a diagnosis-based social program. Both positions deserve respect.

What can a college control?

Not a person's feelings. It can control whether expectations are clear, whether staff respond respectfully, whether students have reliable routes to help, whether student groups can exist on their own terms, and whether policies punish difference unnecessarily.

This is where Fals-Borda becomes useful. Instead of asking leaders to guess what belonging should look like, give students influence over decisions and ask how the institution changed as a result.

What would we measure?

Ask students about belonging directly, but also measure the conditions around it: participation without pressured disclosure; confidence in asking questions; how long accommodations take; whether a disagreement can be repaired; whether students have influence over the decisions that affect them.

Do not report that a campus is inclusive because 94% of staff attended an awareness workshop. That measures attendance at a workshop.

What would change our minds? Well-designed longitudinal work that compares concrete campus changes with students' experiences and outcomes, while paying attention to who was included in the research.